Action Alert: Senate Passes Harmful Permitting Bill- Advocacy Shifts to the House

Last night, the Senate voted 62-33 on final passage of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA). Despite strong pushes from preservation advocates to strike the harmful historic preservation provisions included in Title III of the bill, the Senate ultimately did not consider any additional amendments. Our fight is not over. Advocacy now shifts to the House, where it will be critical for Representatives hear from you on the devastating impact this bill will have!

Thanks in large part to the tireless efforts of preservation advocates, BAAJA’s historic preservation provisions emerged as a major sticking point in the Senate debate. An amendment proposed by Sen. Adam Schiff (D-CA) to strike the historic preservation title entirely, garnered 37 cosponsors, and leaders were negotiating possible changes to the title up until the last minute. We must build on that momentum as the bill moves to the House.

This bill presents the biggest threat to the National Historic Preservation Act in the law’s 60 year history.

The House is scheduled to return from the Thanksgiving holiday on Dec. 1st and could move to consider BAAJA quickly. We need to keep up our advocacy. Keep calling. Keep emailing. Representatives needs to hear from you!


TAKE ACTION TODAY!

1. Call your Representative. Dial 202-224-3121, identify yourself as a constituent and ask to be connected to your Representative’s office. Urge them to stand up for our historic places and VOTE NO on the BAAJA permitting reform bill.

Script: “Hello, my name is [NAME], and I’m a constituent from [CITY/TOWN]. I’m calling to urge [REPRESENTATIVE NAME] to VOTE NO on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act. This bill was negotiated behind closed doors and fails to consider the serious concerns raised by the historic preservation community. The bill incudes dangerous provisions that would decimate preservation reviews, shut out state, Tribal, and local voices, and put historic places in our community directly in harms way.

This bill will lead to more conflict and more delay, while having devastating consequences on the historic places that power tourism and local economies.

I urge the Representative to stand up for our historic places and VOTE NO on the BAAJA permitting reform bill. Thank you for your consideration”

If you don’t get through, keep trying. If you leave a message be sure to provide your name and zip code.

2. Send an email. Preservation Action has made it easy for you to edit and send a letter to your Representative TODAY. It only takes a couple of minutes. If you have personal contact in your Senator or Representative’s office, reach out to that person directly.

Send Your Letter

3. Thank Senators who voted no. If your Senator voted no on BAAJA, be sure to thank them! [See the list →]

4. Forward this alert to your members and partners.


Additional talking points

  • It shuts communities out. It cuts the public out of the process entirely, weakens consultation with State and Tribal Historic Preservation Offices and lets federal agencies override preservation concerns unilaterally.
  • It means less review. Nearly all federally funded projects would be exempt, and many visual, atmospheric, and audible impacts wouldn’t count as harm.
  • It won’t make permitting faster. Cutting out the people who know these places best means more conflict and more delay.
  • It was rushed. It was written behind closed doors, with no committee hearing and no input from the preservation community.

The House could move very quickly, we must keep up the pressure. Your advocacy is having an impact!

Senate Permitting Bill Update- Keep Up Your Advocacy!

Last night the Senate held a procedural vote to end debate on the manger’s amendment to the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA/ S. 5653, H.R 2347). The Senate passed the motion by a vote of 70-27, with 25 Democrats and 2 Republicans voting against. This sets up a final vote on the bill by the end of the week, as the Senate aims to pass BAAJA and send it to the House ahead of the Thanksgiving break.

One unknown is if the Senate will allow for votes on additional amendments, including the amendment led by Sen. Adam Schiff (D-CA), which would strip the bill’s historic preservation title (Title III) from the bill. If passed by the Senate, the bill would move to the House after the Thanksgiving break, where the bill’s prospects remain uncertain. A number of Representatives have expressed serious concerns about the Senate bill.

One thing is clear, your advocacy is making a difference! The National Historic Preservation Act provisions are emerging as a major sticking point to the bill. Several Senators have cited the preservation provisions when explaining their opposition to the bill. Additionally, Sen. Schiff’s amendment to strip Title III continues to gain steam, with 35 Senators now signed on to the amendment as a cosponsor.

The fight isn’t over, keep up your advocacy!

With a final vote in the Senate expected as soon as this week, we need to keep up the pressure. Keep calling. Keep writing.

  • Urge your Senators to support Sen. Schiff’s amendment to strike harmful historic preservation provisions from the permitting bill. If the amendment is not adopted, ask them to VOTE NO on the final bill!

The bill could move to the House quickly, so we also need to be reaching out to Representatives now.

  • Urge your Representative to REJECT the Senate permitting bill as it is currently drafted and work to strike harmful historic preservation provisions from the final bill.

Check out our latest action alert for phone scripts, sample letters, and additional resources to ass your advocacy efforts.

Action Alert: Final Senate Vote on Permitting Bill Expected Soon- Tell Congress to VOTE NO

Earlier this week, the Senate voted 73-25 to advance and open debate on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA, S. 5653, H.R 2347). This vote is extremely disappointing, but the fight is not over. While the bill’s lead sponsors negotiated some modest changes to the bill’s historic preservation title ahead of that vote, these changes did not go nearly far enough and left the bill’s central flaws in place.

A group of Senators led by Sen. Adam Schiff (D-CA) has proposed an amendment that would remove the harmful historic preservation title entirely.

This bill presents the biggest threat to the National Historic Preservation Act in the law’s 60 year history.

The Senate is expected to hold a final vote on the bill as soon as next week, Congress needs to hear from you!

TAKE ACTION TODAY!

1. Call your Senators. Dial 202-224-3121, ask for your Senator’s office, and say you’re a constituent. Urge them to support Sen. Schiff’s amendment to strike harmful historic preservation provisions from the permitting bill. If the amendment is not adopted, ask them to VOTE NO on the final bill!

Script: “Hello, my name is [NAME], and I’m a constituent from [CITY/TOWN]. I’m calling to urge [SENATOR NAME] to support Sen. Schiff’s amendment to strike Title III, the historic preservation title, from the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act, and to VOTE NO on the final bill if the amendment is not adopted. These dangerous provisions would decimate preservation reviews, shut out state, Tribal, and local voices, and put historic places in our community directly in harms way.

This bill will lead to more conflict and more delay, while having devastating consequences on the historic places that power tourism and local economies. The bill was written behind closed doors and is being rushed to a vote without hearings.

I urge the Senator to support Sen. Schiff’s amendment to strike Title III from the permitting bill and VOTE NO on the final bill if the amendment is not adopted. Thank you for your consideration”

2. Send an email. Preservation Action has made it easy for you to edit and send a letter to your members of Congress TODAY. It only takes a couple of minutes. If you have personal contact in your Senator or Representative’s office, reach out to that person directly.

Send Your Letter →

3. Thank Senators who voted no. If your Senator voted no on the motion to proceed to BAAJA, be sure to thank them! [See the list →]

4. Forward this alert to your members and partners.

Additional talking points

  • It shuts communities out. It weakens consultation with State and Tribal Historic Preservation Offices and lets federal agencies override preservation concerns on their own.
  • It means less review. Nearly all federally funded projects would be exempt, and many visual, atmospheric, and audible impacts wouldn’t count as harm.
  • It won’t make permitting faster. Cutting out the people who know these places best means more conflict and more delay.
  • It was rushed. It was written behind closed doors, with no committee hearing and no input from the preservation community.

The Senate is moving fast, and so must we. If the lines are busy, keep calling. If you’ve already reached out, reach out again. Every call and email counts before next week’s vote!

Senate Votes to Advance Permitting Reform- The Fight Continues!

Yesterday the Senate voted 73-25 to advance and open debate on the legislative vehicle for the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA, S. 5653). The vote was opposed by 24 Democrats and 1 Republican. Preservation Action is dismayed by this vote. We remain committed to fighting this harmful legislation and defending the National Historic Preservation Act.

While this vote is a setback, the process is far from over. The vote allows for the bill to be debated and amended, but it is not the final vote. In fact some Senators may vote to open to debate, but still end up opposing the final bill. Our fight continues!

Ahead of vote, Preservation Action joined hundreds of advocates for the 106 Strong Coalition Rally outside the capitol, who made their opposition to this harmful bill known. We appreciate the work of the coalition in organizing the rally and all of those that showed up and spoke out.

We need you to keep up your advocacy! A final Senate vote could come as soon as next week and Congress needs to continue to hear from you.

Reach out to your Senators and Representatives and tell them to oppose the bill! Or encourage them to pass an amendment to completely strike the Title III historic preservation provisions. Check out our action alert to see phone scripts, send emails to your members of Congress, and learn more about this harmful bill.


We also encourage you to be sure to thank those 25 Senators that stood up and voted against this harmful permitting bill and encourage them to talk to their colleagues about their concern.

Senators who voted NO on the motion to proceed to BAAJA:

  • Alsobrooks (D-MD)
  • Baldwin (D-WI)
  • Bennet (D-CO)
  • Blunt Rochester (D-DE)
  • Booker (D-NJ)
  • Cantwell (D-WA)
  • Duckworth (D-IL)
  • Durbin (D-IL)
  • Hassan (D-NH)
  • Hirono (D-HI)
  • Kaine (D-VA)
  • Kelly (D-AZ)
  • Lujan (D-NM)
  • Markey (D-MA)
  • Merkley (D-OR)
  • Murray (D-WA)
  • Padilla (D-CA)
  • Rounds (R-SD)
  • Sanders (I-VT)
  • Schiff (D-CA)
  • Smith (D-MN)
  • Van Hollen (D-MD)
  • Warren (D-MA)
  • Welch (D-VT)
  • Wyden (D-OR)

Manager’s Amendment Makes Modest Changes to Permitting Bill But Leaves Central Flaws in Place

Preservation Action remains strongly opposed to the harmful preservation provisions in the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (S. 5653), as revised by the manager’s amendment released over the weekend. This bill is severely flawed and would have a devastating impact on core historic preservation protections afforded by the National Historic Preservation Act.

The amendment makes some modest changes, but it leaves the bill’s central flaws in place. The bill continues to completely cut the public out of the process and fundamentally weaken meaningful consultation with states and tribes. Federal officials would still have the unilateral authority to set aside mitigation whenever they decide other considerations outweigh historic preservation. Additionally, the bill would still severely limit the courts’ ability to stop the destruction of historic places. While the amendment includes tweaks on when Section 106 review would apply, it continues to exclude nearly all federally funded projects from review and limit what impacts count as harm.

Section 106 works because it brings communities to the table before decisions are final. These changes would not make permitting faster. They would shut out the people who know these places best, and they would lead to more conflict and delay.

Preservation Action supports making federal permitting more efficient and predictable, and we stand ready to work with Congress on real reforms. But this bill was written behind closed doors without input from the historic preservation community and completely upends a 60-year-old law that communities across the country depend on.

We continue to urge Congress to OPPOSE on this deeply flawed bill without the complete removal of the historic preservation title. In light of the growing vocal opposition to this bill, we ask the Senate to reconsider their approach.